Edmund Has Escaped the Dungeon

Posted September 28, 2009 9:02 am by fantasia_kitty

Skandar’s official website has updated again to state, “Edmund has been removed from the dungeon.” There’s been a lot of speculation as to what this dungeon might be. The most logical guess based off of the book is he and the others were being held captive by Pug and the slavers. But it’s good to know that he’s managed to break free somehow and is off filming another scene.

Thanks to Zoe and Rose for the heads-up!

138 Comments For This Story

  • narniaismylife says:

    cool

  • Azon the Narnian says:

    Hmmmmmmmmm… If this is the dungeon in Narrow Haven shoulden’t the rest of the children be with him? Maybe they were filming a scene where he is in the dungeon by himself, after Lucy and Eustace and Reepicheep get taken awy to be sold in the auction, and they will film Lucy, Eustace, and Reep in the dungeon later. That would be a very emotional scene in the movie if lucy was being forced away from Edmund, not knowing if she will ever see him again.

    • Malfhok says:

      I think that even if the others were shooting in the same scene/dungeon, Skandar’s Web site wouldn’t mention it, since his site is about, um, Skandar. πŸ™‚

    • Mirima Rosetrader says:

      Good point, Azon. That would be a sad scene.

      • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

        That’d b cool, Azon. But as 7chronicles said in the other link, it’d be nice if this were, like, a scene that Edmund remembered with Mr. Tummnus and how he betrayed his own family. And I think that’s a good idea, if 7chronicles is readin this. But Azon’s idea is good too! Both are terricfic ideas. Which one, which one…

    • pselpevensie says:

      that really would be emotional, but it might be a good scene for them to add i the movie.

      • Please Type Here says:

        oh yes! a scene liek that between Lu and Ed would be heart-wrenching, but wonderful!

      • narnian resident says:

        that would be a really cool scene, it would be an emotional scene and it would show the relationship between these siblings. afterall, Edmund and Lucy get much closer in this story. it would be so awesome to see Lucy fighting to get back to Edmund when she’s wrenched away

      • skandargirl_95 says:

        I can imagine people starting to cry in the cinemas…aww!
        that WOULD be a sweet scene!

      • Alslan's Meadow says:

        I say they put it in 105%!!!!!!

      • WillandSkandarcrush! says:

        Yes, it’s a great idea to put in the movie! And woudln’t it be more better if Edmund pulled out his sword and started to fight to get back to Lucy or something? just a thought….

      • narniafan4ever says:

        that would be great! And very emotional…especially if Edmund still gets carried away. I’m starting to cry just thinking about it! πŸ™

      • NarniaFreak says:

        oh that would be soo cool. pleese have it in the movie!!! i would cry…

    • aravistarkheena says:

      OMBB!!! That makes me cry just thinking about it!:(

    • JadistarkilleR says:

      i was thinking of the Narrowhaven/ slave market scene as well. but despite the fact that it is Skandar’s official site (and therefore all news would concern only himself), i couldnt shake the feeling that this scene will play slightly differently from what we’re expecting. it could very well be that Edmund is alone in all this, either getting into prison and/or getting out of it.

      also didnt they say that the prison set that they’re using is still somewhere in Cleveland Point? i guess its not quite the last day of filming yet, despite that we got two reports saying that _so and so day_ is the last day πŸ˜€

    • Narnia&The_North says:

      Yes, that would be a great scene… it would make their rescue and reunion so much more dramatic and emotional. I can’t wait to see how all these bits of news we’re getting play out in the film! πŸ™‚

    • georgie-fan says:

      that is such a good idea, you should be the director of this movie!lol

  • Lyssa Pevensie says:

    Thats a good point Azon the Narnian, I never thought of that. But whatever it is, Im glad there is a dungeon in the movie. That is going to be so cool!

  • Edmund-is-hot says:

    OOOOOH! It gets interesting and exciting by the minute! And yes, Azon the Narnian has a VERY good point.

  • Lutra's Pearl says:

    Very intresting. I can wait to see the movie, I can’t believe that we have to wait over 14 months before it comes out. Keep the story of Aslan alive!

  • narniafan4ever says:

    Horray! Edmund is saved! πŸ™‚ lol. I wonder where the other kids are. That would be a really emotional scene if they mix it up and have Edmund left behind…..But, in the book Eustace was the one who wasn’t sold. Hm…. Anyway, it is good to see that they are still making good progress! Sail on Dawn Treader! 14 months seems like an eternity right now. πŸ™

    • NarnianHarpist says:

      Ha ha, I hope they include Pug’s "Nobody wanted to buy Sulky – had to throw him in free" bit!

      • Caspian says:

        ;D lol no kidding! Best part of the book! (well…debatably, of course. If they leave out the limerick someone’s going to be very angry.)

      • narniafan4ever says:

        I know! That part makes me laugh. πŸ™‚ I really hope that put all that stuff in there that has to do with characterizing Eustace as a total brat. lol

      • Starlily says:

        Yeah, they need to put something in the movie that shows what a "record stinker" (I think that’s how Edmund says it) Eustace is.

      • narniafan4ever says:

        The funny thing is, Edmund was a brat in the LWW, but Eustace is like 5 times worse! It’s ironic and hilarious at the same time. πŸ™‚

      • Lucille Brown says:

        I just hope they have both the limerick and that part about Pug not being able to sell him.

      • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

        Actually, Edmund was worse. Because, Eustace was a spoiled bratty child, but Edmund would’ve killed his own family for a crown and candy. Edmund said so himself in the book when Eustace and him talk about how Eustace meets Aslan. I quote Edmund:"You were only an ass, but I was a traitor…"
        PS. Sorry for the bad word, I did NOT mean it. But that’s exactly what it says in the book.
        CANNOT wait 4 the movie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

        Aslan is one the Move!

      • narniafan4ever says:

        That is true! I remember that from the book, now. πŸ™‚

    • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

      Well, this IS from Skandar’s official website, so… Why would they have the others included if it’s his website. You never know, it could be the rest as well or just him.

  • ernesto torres chΓ‘vez says:

    no es gusto que edmund espere toda la internidad jajajajaja pero bueno bye

  • Narnia Girl says:

    More interesting by the minute. Oh, I am dying for the movie…ahhhh. narniafan4ever is right, 14 months seems like an eternity right now. πŸ˜›

  • Caspian says:

    Probably the reason they only mentioned Skandar in the dungeon is because this is from a Skandar fansite. Lu and Eustace might have been there without them pointing it out. Interesting to think they might have been separated, though…

  • Aslan's my homeboy says:

    Yeah I read that las night on his website I’m glad he is out πŸ™‚

  • narnia365 says:

    Well, that’s good. Can’t wait to see the movie! I wonder what they are filming RIGHT NOW…

    • Puddleglum says:

      That was my question.
      Does anyone know where the next round of filming is to take place?

      • narnia_insider says:

        The next round of filming is to take place at the studios at Movieworld. Filming there has already begun.

      • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

        It takes place at the Golden Coast in California. Tamara (best narnian spy in the world) reported that.

      • better_narnia_spy_than_tamara!!!!!!!!!!!!! says:

        I was there at Cleveland Point for nearly all the filming, got to meet all the stars
        The next filming location is NOT at the Golden Coast in California!!!! It IS at Warner Brothers Movie World Studios GOLD COAST QUEENSLAND AUSTRALIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

      • better_narnia_spy_than_tamara!!!!!!!!!!!!! says:

        If you STILL don’t believe me, go to this address http://www.narniafans.com/archives/7352 and READ FOR YOURSELF!!

        The water tank received $500,000 in State Government funding. The Voyage of the Dawn Treader will begin shooting late next week at the huge set built at The Spit. Exterior shots on board the ship will be filmed at Cleveland Point in September and interior shots inside the ship filmed at Warner Roadshow Studios.

        SEE?????!!!

      • better_narnia_spy_than_tamara!!!!!!!! says:

        And if any of you have any more questions for me, please don’t hesitate to ask!

        It’s not like I’m going to bite your head off…

      • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

        NO, you’re NOT better than Tamara, and Tamara herself said so. But who cares where it is, I’m just happy there’s a movie! And nothing can change my mind about Tamara. I’m not kidding, even if you say Skandar Keynes is ugly(which he’s not), I’ll never change my mind! πŸ™‚

      • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

        I meant that Tamara said so herself that it was in California. Sorry, mistakes coming.
        CANNOT wait 4 the movie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

      • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

        And why the yelling? I mean, this isn’t an arguement, just a misunderstanding, okay? I don’t like to get into fights with people. Even on the computer where no one can get injured. Fighting is just not my thing.

      • narniafan4ever says:

        okay, you two. That is enough. πŸ˜€ We have not seen any reports from you yet, so you can’t claim that you are better than Tamara without proof. Sorry, but it’s the truth! πŸ™‚ Tamara has been doing great so far!!!! πŸ˜€

      • narniafan4ever says:

        btw…I was talking to you, "better_spy_than_tamara!!!!!!" .

      • Aravis(narniafan#1) says:

        No offense, narniafan4ever, but maybe we should stay out of this. I mean, this is sort of personal… but if anyone thinks Tamara is a great spy can post on this comment. Please, I’d like to know who likes Tamara the best.

      • Aravis(narniafan#1) says:

        narnia insider, are you the same person as better_narnian_spy_than_tamara?

      • narniafan4ever says:

        Oops! I’m so sorry! I didn’t realize that it was personal. πŸ™ I thought is was just playful banter…that’s why I commented. So, sorry about that guys! And, no offence taken. πŸ˜€

      • better_narnia_spy_than_tamara!!!!!!!! says:

        No, I’m not the same person as that narniainsider person, don’t know who that is!
        Well maybe I am better than her lol because if she says its in california and it’s not – then clearly she cant be better! Ugh no need to bite my head off haha lol. just sayin…

      • better_narnia_spy_than_tamara!!!!!!!! says:

        and btw if it was tamara that reported the warehouse they filmed in for 2 days last week was in Russle St Cleveland, then that was wrong also!
        Because I drove around that street for ages trying to find it, and all there is on that road is houses, a school, pool and a cemetery. No warehouses! So yeah..

      • Martha Pevensie says:

        Aravis(narniafan#1), I also thought this was a playful banner thing. As WillMoseleyandSkandar said, she hates fights! So It’s not personal. And I think Tamara is the BEST spy EVER!!!!!!!!!

  • Narniamiss says:

    I wonder what this exactly means. It could just mean they are all done with filming the dungeon scene, and are moving on. I hope that is all it means.

  • Mirima Rosetrader says:

    Yay Edmund has escaped from the evil clutches of Pug! Cannot wait to see that scene when the movie comes out! So excited! *sighs* It’s seems like an age when it will come out, but these reports help the wait. And when the trailer comes out I will be watching it almost every day! I hope it will come out in December! Sail on VDT!

  • Lady Polly says:

    Great Now What?

  • 220chrisTian says:

    Azon, Malfhok, and Caspian: good points. Let’s pray God uses this scene to wake up Skandar and others who are spiritual prisoners and slaves to sin.

    • daughter of the King says:

      That’s a great thought.

    • narniafan4ever says:

      Amen! I have been praying for the whole cast, to be honest. πŸ™‚ I really hope that they can all come to know Jesus as their Best Friend and Savior. πŸ™‚

    • redeemedqueen says:

      Amen! They live in a country that is becoming more and more Godless…They really need our prayers…I can’t understand how they can be in a series of movies with so much christian symbolism, and yet be so blind…especially Skandar (considering his character, which is my favorite…He does an amazing job…)…it’s so ironic…

      • narniafan4ever says:

        i totally agree with you. I mean, Edmund’s character is such an awesome one (probably my favorite as well). It shows that even those who reject Christ at one point in their life can eventually be saved and changed by the Ultimate Healer and Giver. I think Lucy’s character is my second favorite cause it seems to represent that child-like faith that we as Christians should have. Yay, Jesus! And yay Aslan! πŸ™‚

    • WillMoseleyandSkanarcrush! says:

      Preach it brother!…or sister?

  • Dr Elwin Ransom says:

    When reading that title I couldn’t help but think of "Elvis has left the building." πŸ˜‰

    • Narniangirl says:

      LOL nice another owner of PC: The illustrated Movie Companion. The profile on Skandar and the others I have to say is my favourite part of the book, very well written. WOO can’t wait for the trailer! (i know I’m getting ahead of myself but I can dream!"

      • narniafan4ever says:

        Hey, you’re not the only one who is is dreaming right now. πŸ™‚ I’m on the same ship as you. I know I already said this, but 14 months seems like an eternity. πŸ™‚

      • narniafan4ever says:

        I guess it is a good exercise for my patience, you know? πŸ™‚

  • Molly says:

    Okay, here’s some speculation (cue salt shakers): could Edmund be a hostage of the Dufflepuds? Maybe they are holding him to a "ransom" of Lucy breaking the invisibility spell. It sounds like something they might do. Then again, I don’t think Lucy would need such coercion. Just a thought!

    • narniafan4ever says:

      That is an interesting thought. But the Dufflepuds are really, well….ahem….stupid in the book. Like, they can’t think for themselves and are kind of like blind sheep following their leader (the head dufflepud).

      • Molly says:

        Yes they’re foolish and silly but they are at the same time somewhat menacing. Invisible people with invisible weapons who blindly follow a proud, thoughtless and somewhat undiplomatic leader…
        Still, I acknowledge that to do this the filmmakers would have to change the spirit of their adventure on Coriakin’s island. But I wouldn’t put it past them!

    • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

      Good thought! I’ve heard so many creative thoughts so far(or should I say read :)) ) and they’re all loveley! I wish they’d use them all in the movie. You all should totally write a letter to the director and tell him your ideas. I REALLY REALLY REALLY wanna see these in the movie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      And I can’t wait for the movie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! πŸ™

  • Braden Woodburn says:

    Yay he’s free hehe!

  • narnian resident says:

    cool. i just love to hear movie news! this is interesting. hey, wouldnt it be cool if Edmund suddenly took out his sword and fought to get the others back? fought for Lucy? that would be cool, but i dont think they would do it. just a thought!

    • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

      Wonderful suggestion, narnia resident! All these things I’m reading are GREAT ideas. I still seriously think you guys should send your ideas to the director!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ˜‰

      • narnian resident says:

        yeah but how on earth could you do that? and they would already have the script written, so i dont think sending an idea would work.

  • spottedmask says:

    Yay! Good for him…at least I think thats good

  • King Skandar the Just says:

    Yay! I hope you get back together with Caspian soon!

  • Mark Friedrich says:

    I a gree with Azon the Narnian

  • GlimGlum says:

    So Skandar acted well enough for Edmund to move on to other scenes. But that’s no surprise since Skandar has done such a good job portraying him in LWW and PC. πŸ™‚
    Keep it up Skandar! Looking froward to the VDT version of Edmund.

  • Last King of Narnia says:

    Whew! thank the Great Lion he is free now πŸ˜‰
    ~Further up and Further in~

  • pselpevensie says:

    YAY! EDMUND ESCAPED!

  • Anonymous Narnian says:

    Agreed, Azon. I’d love to see Georgie handle that scene if that’s how it turned out to be. I’m glad Eddie’s free, at least.

  • Mark Friedrich says:

    When I first saw Georgie, I thought to myself yes this is girl that should play Lucy because she does it so perfectly.

  • ASLAN'S CHILD says:

    i dont know what this dungeon means but at least he broke free.lol.

  • Narnia Lover says:

    Oh my gosh! I can’t wait to see the movie! And that seance sounds ALSOME!!!! πŸ˜€ SAIL ON VDT!!!!!! πŸ˜€

    • Narnian Jesus Freakβ™₯(used to be celtic13) says:

      What seance??

      • narniafan4ever says:

        NO!!!!!!!!!! not a seance! That would ruin the whole movie! It is supposed to have a clean, christian feel to it!

    • Starlily says:

      Seance??? Don’t scare me! Calling up the White Witch in Prince Caspian was more than enough occultism for me!

      • narniafan4ever says:

        Agreed! And just an FYI….seances are so evil and demonic. It is so dangerous and should not be practiced at all, let alone be put into such an awesome movie like this. πŸ™‚

    • Joy. says:

      What’s a seance?

      • narniafan4ever says:

        It’s when people recite chants to "bring up the dead" and "talk with them". But what the people that do it don’t know is that they are really talking to fallen angels who make themselves look like the deceased person they are trying to communicate with. It is really a scary and evil thing.
        And know that…This is a hard thing to describe to someone when I don’t know what their beliefs regarding religion is, so I hope this helps you understand and that I didn’t offend anyone. πŸ˜€

      • Joy says:

        Thanks! πŸ™‚

      • Joy says:

        And my belief of religion is Christianity.

      • narniafan4ever says:

        Yeah, my belief is in Jesus, too. Just making sure. πŸ˜€ So, nice to meet you, fellow sis! πŸ™‚

      • Starlily says:

        narniafan4ever, that’s just what I believe! It’s neat to connect on Narniaweb, isn’t it? πŸ™‚

      • Starlily says:

        Meaning the part about the seance, and Jesus. By the way, don’t seances make you think of King Saul in the Bible going to the witch to call up Samuel?

        I hope no one minds us having these discussions which don’t have much to do with the news story.

      • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

        I’m a chritain too, Joy! It’s so exciting to know someone else is a christain. And Starlily, I don’t remember that part in the Bible. Would you tell what chapter and book that’s in. I’d like to read it.

      • Joy says:

        WOW! isn’t it nice to know other Christians? What’s your favorite book in the Bible? Mine is Revelation.

      • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

        Mine is Revelation too! It’s the best book in the Bible ever!!!!!

      • narniafan4ever says:

        yes, that is a good point. πŸ™‚ It is so awesome to meet fellow sisters and brothers in Christ!
        And I like Revelation, too. It is so cool to see how it is playing out today! And you wouldn’t believe how many pastors and people have told me to not read it because it is something that no one would understand. But, the name "Revelation" is about the revealing of Jesus and His fulfillment of Prophecy! Plus, it ways that those who read Revelation will be blessed. πŸ˜€
        I love Jesus! He is so awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! πŸ˜€ πŸ˜€ πŸ˜€ (and I’m not just saying that…I mean it! πŸ™‚ )

      • narniafan4ever says:

        btw….Is is just me, or does your heart start to race with excitement the minute you start talking about Jesus? πŸ˜€

      • Starlily says:

        WillMoselyandSkandarcrush (woo, long name!) the story about King Saul and the witch of Endor is found in I Samuel 28 verses 3 and on. It’s a spooky story, and also sad because Saul lost hope and favor with God, and commited suicide in battle. But it’s also interesting.
        And narniafan4ever, do people really tell you not to read Revelation? That’s too bad. It has so much information in it about the last days. And yes, when I started reading your comments about how you believe in Jesus, my heart did race! Like I said before, it’s nice to connect.

      • narniafan4ever says:

        Yes, Starlily; Many people have said not to read it. I mean, when I eventually did read it, I read with a lot of caution because I heard it was all about Dragons and Angels and Plagues and destruction. But, once I learned how to understand prophecy and what all the symbolize represents, it gave my such comfort to know that God wrote it down for us to understand so we could be prepared for Jesus’ return. And I am so glad that I did read it. Now I have a better idea of why it seems as though the world is going stark-raving mad and falling apart. πŸ™‚ Jesus is my only hope!!!!!! Yay! πŸ˜€ πŸ˜€ πŸ˜€

      • Starlily says:

        Yes, if I didn’t believe in Jesus and his coming, I think I would get depressed and be scared of everything. How do people function without a hope in Jesus? And yes, Revelation is a great blessing, full of vital information about the last days. My favorite part is the end, where it talks about heaven. Let’s keep studying the Word, narniafan4ever, because we know there are many more truths to uncover! πŸ˜€

      • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

        Heh! Imagine, all this talk about our heavenly Father started with a seance! Weird. And narnia4ever, my heart does speed up when this conversation started! Is it just me, or is this fun?

      • narniafan4ever says:

        Yes, willmoseleyandskandarcrush; this a lot of fun! πŸ˜€
        And yes, sadly many people did tell me not to read Revelation. But we as Christians need to be staying strong because it seems as though Satan is really "turning up the heat", if you will, and trying more than ever to keep people deceived…..Even fellow Brothers and Sisters in Christ! So, yes….We need to be digging in God’s Word more than ever to stay in contact with our Daddy (God) and not be deceived as so many are being today.
        Keep Your eyes on Jesus and His eternal reward for us that is to come! πŸ˜€

  • pixiedust says:

    would this have anything to do with that clip of Lucy calling out to Edmund from the ship? maybe he’s getting taken to the dungeon?

  • coracle says:

    It could just be that the ‘dungeon’ is a holding cell for slaves before the market day. Edmund is in it while waiting to be sold, and then he is taken out to be sold!
    I expect it’ll follow the book in that of their group only Eustace is left unsold.

    • narniafan4ever says:

      sure hope so….then they can add the "no one want’s sulky, here….had to throw him in free and no one would touch him…"

  • wunderkind42 says:

    OR MAYBE SKANDER WENT TO JAIL????
    For drugs??

    • WillMoseleyandSkandarcrush! says:

      WWHHAATT!?!?!?!?!?! What in he world are you talking about?! πŸ™ πŸ™ πŸ™

  • wunderkind42 says:

    Just kidding πŸ˜€

  • Eden says:

    When I saw the title I just had to LOL. πŸ˜€ But I’m glad that Eddie has escaped. XD Can’t wait to see the movie!
    COME SOON VotDT!

  • Jewel the Unicorn says:

    Whew! Close one!

  • Narnian Ricky says:

    I don’t remember a dungeon in the book.

  • heeey says:

    Wow thats good.

  • georgie-fan says:

    yup,that happend in the book!

  • NarniaLuver4Ever says:

    Well that’s good to know! LOL

  • NarniaGeek says:

    Woo…go Edmund! πŸ˜›

  • Sydney says:

    Progress is Good. Thanks for the news! πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚ πŸ™‚
    __ __
    / \/ \
    \ /
    \ /
    \ /
    \/
    /

  • Sokol_iz_Narnii says:

    King Caspian has released Edmund, Lucy, Reepicheep and Eustace ("Dawn Treader" – Chapter 3 and 4).

  • narniafan4ever says:

    OH MY GOSH!!!!!!!!!!!!! I AM GETTING SO EXCITED!!!!!!!! πŸ˜€

  • Sandra says:

    Wow!That’s awesome

  • SusanStorm says:

    Dude. If they write him out of this movie, too, I will be very unhappy. I repeat – very unhappy. More like strongly upset.