Do You Want a Sequel?
Boxofficemojo.com is curretnly featuring a poll on the front page of their site asking the question whether or not people want to see a sequel made for The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader. Voters must have an account with the site, which they can create for free. You can find the poll on boxofficemojo.com’s front page, by clicking here.
I want them to make all seven films. This is my opinion of books:
1. HHB
2. VDT
3. LB
4. SC
5. LWW
6. MN
7. PC
SC NEEDS TO BE MADE. It's my favorite one, and come on, who doesn't want to see Puddleglum on the big screen?
wow, tradition, you put it perfectly- and little enjoyable interaction between loving family members, with them all being so grouchy
so that must be why it won the Carnegie Medal of Honor for the year-
you must be a big action lover-eh? Mine are- 1)-LWW 2 )LB 3)HHB 4)MN 5)PC 6)VDT 7)SC PC is probably higher on the list cause I saw the movie first
SC! yeah! I want them all!
Remember when Peter Jackson's LotR trilogy came out? The first 2 were virtually ignored by the Oscars, while Return of the King took the Oscars by storm, even though it didn't get any more critical acclaim than the other two. The awards for the final installment were, for all intents and purposes, awards for the series as a whole. I suspect something like that happened in the case of the Carnegie Medal. Officially, they awarded that particular book, but they were actually awarding Lewis for the series as a whole.
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I hope they get a good actor for Puddleglum!
Yeah I guess I like action. I love Prince Caspian but I just like the other ones better.
I can imagine a reboot as a miniseries of all 7 books, then to dvd, sold as a set, made by a deeply christian company who will make the series with the main point to develop the spiritual themes. Not to make shallow popcorn flicks.
in this day and age, they could actually make a really intense, realistic animated series that could be deeply engrossing.
maybe use the radio theatre version, use that script and give to a pixar level company.
if you can dream it, you can do it,- start a grassroots social networking movement to get support and then contact walden with the results, use facebook, twitter, blogs, submit articles to magazines, call radio stations and get on the air talking about how great it was, etc. they really look to these things to gauge support for their monetary gamble.
my main attraction was the pevensies too, i had a hard time getting into the others as much. i wish he had included them popping in to the other books somehow, at least. and HHB could be so gorgeous, I imagine an alladin disney look for it, really colorful and mysterious, what fools disney are.
Errrr yes. I want all of them and I want to be in them or at least one of them.
my favorite order would be:1.LWW
2.VDT
3.MN
4.PC
5.LB
6.HHB
7.SC
Please dooooooooooooooo! Silver Chair must be the next one I think. The actors will grow too big if they wait longer. I'd love to see the whole 7 books be made into movies though. My favorite goes this way:
LWW–wonderful story about redemption and Narnia!!!!!
VDT–great epic voyage with lots of fun and adventure!
SC–richly dark, ironically funny and full of meaning!
HHB–lovely plot, great story!
LB–beautiful ending to a great series!
MN–a good story, but a little wierd with all those rings. Still, hope the whole series becomes a movie set. For Narnia and Long Live Aslan!
yes we would love a sequel!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
YES! YES! YES! They need to do the rest of them. Rebooting the series would be a gigantic waste of time and money, and HBB, MN and LB have NEVER been adapted for any medium.
My order of faves
SC: The richest and darkest book in the series, and the most bankable option for a sequel.
HBB: Although not chronologically important, it was a good story and is the funniest of the series.
VDT: Lots of adventure and excitement galore! Very rich in character development.
LWW: The book which speaks to you most spiritually.
LB: Although confusing, a killer ending to the series.
MN: Interesting.
PC: Nothing really special about it.
1. Last Battle
2. Voyage of the Dawn Treader
3. The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe
4. The Magician's Nephew
5. The Horse and His Boy
6. The Silver Chair
7. Prince Caspian
Sadly, I still haven't seen VoDT yet. (I'm pretty broke right now.) But there is a good reason to vote "No." The first two books were radically altered when they were made into movies. It sounds like there are a lot of changes to VoDT as well. I don't want Hollywood making more Narnia movies if they're going to continue to disrepect the source material so much.
Again, I haven't seen VoDT yet, so maybe my opinion will be different after seeing it. I'm just saying that not everyone who votes "No" is a jerk or a lowlife. 🙂
hell yeah…. another one will be a delight…
Radically?
In the book it says that Puddleglum has a brown complexion. So it wouldn't be weird if they have a person of color in the role. Wil Johnson definitely has both the gravity and the comedic edge. 🙂
That's not true at all. LWW only had very minor differences, PC was a lousy adaptation because
#1. They made some really dumb changes.
#2. A lot of things weren't fully explained.
VDT's differences worked because they made sense.
oh wow, this is a really hard desision….. hmm…. YES I WANT A SEQUEL!!!
I am truly a Narnia Fan and I am so happy that movies are being made to represent the cronicle series. I loved the first two movies made and even understood the adaptions done from book to film. However, "The Voyage of the Dawn Treader" left me deeply disapointed. I feel the basis of the story had completely changed. There was hardly any character developement, and to much liberties taken with the story line. I was looking forward to what I consider my favorite book of the series, and I was very distressed by what I saw. There was so much they could have chosen from Lewis' book, but they made up a good portion of the script from other sources. I want the movies to continue, but I want screen writers to understand that staying as close to the original stories of Narnia, is what will pull the Narnia fans to the theaters. Please consider, and thank you.
No sequel. The new film was pretty much garbage. I'd rather have no Narnia films than under-performing, poorly made Narnia films.
For all of you who want to see The Silver Chair made into a movie (and I do too), you better go see Voyage of the Dawn Treader a couple more times before it leaves the theaters. If we don't support VODT and it doesn't make a profit, there's no reason for them to make another one.
i definetlyy wanna sequell!!!!!!! i loooovvveddd voyagee of the dawnn treaderr!!!
I love polls. And of course, I want another movie. I'd like to see them make all of them. Even BBC made 4 of them. Here's my favorites in order:
1. LWW
2. MN
3. LB
4. VDT
5. SC
6. PC
7. HHB
I'm really hoping they get to do "The Silver Chair" next. In my opinion, the perfect Puddleglum would be Doug Jones (the faun and pale man from "Pan's Labyrinth," Abe Sapien from "Hellboy," and others). He's got the look and build, the acting chops, and has gone on record saying that he really wants the part of Puddleglum if they make it.
Does he have the charisma though?
I agree with you here Reepicheep here
The original series was good, but almost nothing can beat the magic and wonder of LWW which I still adore!
PC was a big disapointment, but BB was pretty good as Caspian
AND it had REEPICHEEP in it!!! who was AMAZING
I agree with you here Reepicheep here
The original series was good, but almost nothing can beat the magic and wonder of LWW which I still adore!
PC was a big disappointment, but BB was pretty good as Caspian
AND it had REEPICHEEP in it!!! who was AMAZING
A few thoughts – this is my first post here, and I love the energy.
One: Please don't even use the word "reboot." It's an awful by-product of the changing legal rights that swirl around certain comic-book characters. Has nothing to do with artistic vision or integrity, and everything to do with going to the well one more time to make a buck. Booooo!!!
Two: Agree with most here that Silver Chair is the obvious next movie, with the strong performance by the actor who played Eustace. And am I misremembering this, or wasn't there some mention of Jill at the end of the Dawn Treader movie?
Three: Generally speaking, I'd love for the filmmakers to follow the original order of the books, not the chronological numbering that later publishers imposed. Oddly, I think if they can make a good (and successful) Silver Chair movie, they'll be over the hump – while I liked the book, I found the villain a little derivative. In fact, I wonder if the filmmakers will do the same, and use Tilda Swanton (I hope so- making a positive out of a negative).
HHB has the potential for a real epic scale and sweep, and as others have observed, the scenes with the Pevensies will work well as they're older. If they do HHB well, they can do whatever they want with MN – which will likely be the most stylistically different of all the films. And it will really whet people's appetite for LB, which I do think has the ability to finish off the series with artistry and beauty.
I hope they realize this: It all builds to The Last Battle. That's the big emotional and spirtitual payoff, and I firmly believe that done right, it will be the biggest commercial and critical success as well (much like Return of the King).
Yes, depending on who would be in charge of producing and directing.
yes but i do think silver chair should go first i really want to play a character in it i come from a poor family not somin to say online but i want to play jill so much i could cry if i was her i wouldnt let the fame go to my head and i just want to do somthing i like especially when it involves narnia nd acting it always seems like im on the out side staring in at my family and friends just this once i want to have fun at somthing get to know the actors the directors plz any detatails plz email me at http://www.ilovebebo@hotmail.co.uk you have to use the www. jus so u know plz make my dream come true if this helps im 12 most likley be 13 when they start filming plz let y dream come true
Hail Fellow Narnians!
I know that this group of individuals stands somewhat divided in regards to the current state and condition of our beloved series, but seeing as how the thing that unites us is our affection and regard for the timeless innocence and priceless simple truths bestowed on us through Aslan and Narnia, permit me to offer some observations I have made looking at the visual adaptation of the series over the years.
I, myself, like some of you, was first introduced to Narnia through the BBC miniseries. After watching LWW at six years old, I was hooked. My grandmother presented me with the books a few years later and I was fully versed in the adventures of Aslan, the Narnians, and the child heroes by age 11. This brings me to my first observation that
1. Not every fan of Narnia read the books first, or has read them yet. The most insightful reviewer I read about VDT began his article by saying that while watching the LOTR films made him want to watch them all over again (I'm inclined to agree with his POV), "watching the Narnia movies makes me want to go read the books". C.S. Lewis would be very encouraged by such a statement as he wrote these books for children in order that they may be given an imaginative introduction to the cosmology and universal principles surrounding the Christian faith (good, evil, and where man stands in relation to them). We want our children to read these books so that by "knowing me(Aslan) a little here(in Narnia)", they may come to "know me(Christ) better there(on Earth)". This, then ties into my second point which is that
2. Because they were written for children, you must become, to use Christ's own words, "like a child" to be able to appreciate and enjoy these stories. The world wants us to become a generation of "Susans" who lost her childlike wonder and humility by trying to act "like a grownup". This is demonstrated with Disney's biggest mistake…they were trying to make the films "grown-up". Most of you don't realize this but the average age of the children called upon by Aslan in these books is about 12. After that point, they are "too old" to return to Narnia. Some people might take this at face value, but what Lewis (and Aslan) meant by that is that while they have reached adolescence and are now ready to enter into the grown-up world, they must always take their time and lessons gained in Narnia with them. Paul, the apostle, put it another way "Stand firm and hold to the teachings we passed on to you", and the author of the Proverbs commands parents to "train up a child in the way he should go, and when he is old, he will not depart from it". Susan matures well, but in the process forgets the lessons she learned there, losing both her innocence and her faith, which is exactly how young minds get primed for the world to "re-educate" them in their fashion. I still watch the BBC miniseries and I can assure you, I am still more impressed by that animatronic puppet-Aslan than I ever was by the very boring CGI image in the Disney films.
Therefore, with this point said, I would suggest that the purists, who have been sorely disappointed by the recent films, as well as the fans, who just want the books made into films, and especially the movie moguls who have the means of creating these films, all need to take the time to take off the cynical, jaded, grown-up eyes of the world when approaching these stories, or else we will simply see the end of a beautiful, timeless collection. There are four more opportunities for us to do this, and all four of them are unique, exciting, compelling stories in their own right. Silver Chair is the most "quest-like" chronicle out of all them with enough "dark" elements to satisfy anyone; Horse and His Boy is the only real love story, hence why it's my favorite :),plus it entails all the elements of a classic high-flying adventure story with a good dosage of character development too; Magician's Nephew answers questions about certain mysteries that LWW never fully explained, namely where the white witch is from, where the lamppost came from, where the wardrobe came from, and especially, how travel between our world and Narnia first began. These first three books all set us up perfectly for the great Finis found in The Last Battle – essentially, everything that we find in Return of the King, except on a younger scale, and also taking a more direct parallel to the book of Revelations, which considering the current state of the world, is not all that irrelevant or pointless. But regardless of your faith, or your relationship with Narnia, the bottom line is that we here share a common bond of love and regard for its magical and adventurous spirit that the cynical critics of this age can never comprehend. Let us never lose that attitude or compromise its vision and we will not only have a "sequel" but we will see a successful adaptation of the remaining four books that will put even Harry Potter fans to shame. (No offense meant if you happen to be both a lover of HP and Narnia). Narnia and the North!!!
About your pt 1, actually that's not true. Lewis wrote the book to teach children about the wonders of imagination, and the traditional style of English story-telling. The religious themes worked their way in as an after thought.
I NEED a sequel! YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I could contest your answer, but I will only make a correction…my first point was about how a lot of current fans of the series were introduced to it through either the recent films or the BBC miniseries then they went back to read the books for themselves…but since after saying this I can't resist, let me say that the fact that Lewis and Tolkien were both respected members of a group of literary masters known as the Christian Apologetics allows a conclusion that they wished to both defend and illustrate the truth of the Christian faith in their works, while also championing the oral virtues and techniques you so ably described that is so beautifully demonstrative in the art of fiction and fantasy-like stories. Yes they were British patriots in many noble ways, but they were defenders of the faith also. However, not wishing to start an argument here, let me just correct myself by adding that why Lewis wrote these is not inescapably relevant to the discussion…I merely slipped that sidenote in there because I know many fans who love this series acknowledge and appreciate the theological symbolism Lewis used taken from the life exemplified by Christ in the Scriptures. I apologize if I didn't make this clear in my article and welcome any further comments or clarification on my response.
Now that everyone is saying her favs I might as well too.
1. LWW – the storyline was fantastic and I will always love it.
2. VDT – I loved how new parts of Narnia were intorduced.
3. MN – I love the idea of the rings and how the wardrobe came to be!
4.SC – Jill/Eustace/Puddleglum were awesome!
5.PC- a bit of a let down compared to LWW
6.HHB – I still liked it it's just that I missed the old characters.
7. LB – I didn't like the fact that Narnia died, especially the bit where the giant sqeezed the sun like an orange.
It has and must be a sequel because every creature and character must be represented if they want to make the last battle. I think the silver chair and the Horse and his boy will have action, and the Magician's nephew is easier to make. so of course i want a sequel.
So when will your novel be published?
Nope!
I really want to see all of the books made but particularly The Magicians Nephew and The Silver Chair. I had hoped to be able to acquire the entire list in Disney movie form because as good as the BBC is they don't have the funds to pull of the special effects right.